Rollins: Stop the Nonsense, the Amercian League Rookie of the Year Race Isn’t Even Close


Okay, let’s pause for a minute Red Sox Nation.

Why am I saying this? Well, after Andrew Benintendi’s two-home run, six-RBI showing Saturday afternoon, apparently the AL Rookie of the Year race, which the 23-year-old was favored to win at the beginning of the season, is a “race” again.

I’m not joking, see for yourself:


Two factors have led to this, as I would say, confusion. One, the left fielder is hitting .484 with four home runs and 11 runs batted in thus far in August. He also have five thefts and 10 runs scored.

The man who Red Sox fans are quick to dethrone from the front-runner status, the New York Yankees’ Aaron Judge, is hitting .161 with five home runs and 12 runs batted in post All-Star break.


So, here is a quick look at the updated numbers for both rookies:

Stat Benintendi Judge
BA .280 .289
HR 16 35
RBI 65 78
OBP .359 .419
R 59 87
H 111 114
SB 14 6

Okay, so it’s blatantly obvious. What I’m getting at is regardless of how hot Benny, as he is referred to by the Fenway faithful, is, the race is still out of hand.

Besides stolen bases, which is essentially meaningless, the one advantage I would give Benintendi is the success of the Red Sox, who sit in first place in the AL East.

However, if you’re a fan of WAR (wins above replacement), you’ll see Judge pulls in at No. 8 in the MLB at 5.3. You’ll have to do some scrolling down to find Benintendi, whose WAR is 1.9.


Judge would have to essentially hit .200 the rest of the way for this to even be close.


Check us out on our socials:   
Twitter: @PTSTNews and @TalkPrimeTime
Facebook Page: Prime Time Sports Talk
Join our Facebook Group: Prime Time Sports Talk 
Instagram: @primetimesportstalk


Share this:

MLB Surprises - Cleveland Guardians 2024
Latest News

Big Surprises Early in 2024 MLB Season

There have been plenty of big surprises in MLB during the first quarter of the season, from surprise teams and players to the rebound of the AL Central. There has been an increase in attendance at the stadiums and in TV viewership. We even saw the streaming service Roku get awarded Sunday baseball games.

Read More
MLB, Philadelphia Phillies, Bryce Harper
Latest News

The Philadelphia Phillies are Rolling

The Philadelphia Phillies are rolling and show no signs of slowing down. We are only at the one-quarter mark of the season, but they have the best record in baseball and are off to their best start through 48 games since 1993.

Read More
Nationals SP Trevor Williams
Latest News

Trevor Williams’ Resurgence Helping Nationals Succeed

Trevor Williams’ resurgence with the Washington Nationals has seen him jump out to a 4-0 record with a 1.96 ERA in seven starts. Williams has yet to surrender a home run, and he’s also one of the reasons why this team is hanging around the .500 mark.

Read More

2 Responses

  1. Judge hasn’t done anything since All-star break.If Andrew keeps it up and Judge continues downward spiral there should be a discussion.Its Rookie of the Year not Rookie of 3 Months

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Browse by Category:

Visit for
hard-hitting KC Chiefs coverage.