Hall of Fame Case: Paul Goldschmidt

Hall of Fame Case: Paul Goldschmidt

by January 22, 2022 4 comments

Paul Goldschmidt won’t be on the ballot for probably another 10 years. He has been one of the best first basemen in the league during his current 12-year career. While he certainly doesn’t get the kind of fanfare many of his contemporaries enjoy, he has been rock solid for the Arizona Diamondbacks and more recently with the St. Louis Cardinals. Unlike most of his fellow first basemen, Goldschmidt steals bases and also plays Gold Glove defense. Let’s take a look at his Hall of Fame case.

Make sure to check out all of our other Hall of Fame Cases.

Career Summary

Paul Edward Goldschmidt was an eighth-round selection of the Diamondbacks in 2009 out of Texas State University. After tearing up the minors and making it to Double-A by 2011, Arizona called him up. He had a solid 48 games that year and took over the starting spot in 2012. Although he played first, Goldy showed off his power-speed combo hitting 20 home runs and stealing 18 bases that season. In 2013, he broke through leading the league in HRs (36) and RBIs (125) while swiping 15 bags and finishing second to Andrew McCutchen in NL MVP voting.

After an injury-shortened 2014, Goldschmidt bounced back and finished second once again in MVP voting, this time to Bryce Harper. From 2013-2018 with Arizona, Goldy averaged 30 homers, 100 runs, 100 RBIs, and 17 SBs. while slashing .301/.406/.541. He was shipped to St. Louis and has been there for three seasons. While his overall production has slipped slightly, Goldschmidt is still a premier first baseman. In 2021 he finished sixth in MVP voting and won his fourth Gold Glove.


Goldschmidt already has some accolades that voters like to see: six All-Star appearances, five top-6 finishes in MVP voting, four Gold Gloves. He currently has 280 HRs and 140 SBs, a rare accomplishment for a first baseman. Only two other players who have played at least 40 percent of their games at first base have reached those numbers, Orlando Cepeda and Jeff Bagwell. While defense is not considered a priority for first basemen the way it is for players in the middle of the diamond, Goldschmidt has been elite in his career ranking fifth all-time in fielding percentage and 13th in Total Zone Runs according to Baseball-Reference.com.


The Cardinals’ first baseman is on a solid track, but as it stands now, he looks like he has a case similar to Mark Teixeira. Goldschmidt has a wOBA of .385 and a 141 wRC+. Through his first 10 seasons, Tex had a .382 wOBA and a 131 wRC+. While Goldy’s baserunning certainly earns him marks, the overall offensive output needs to continue for him to have a chance.


What you do at the plate is what gets you voted in as a first baseman. Todd Helton was an excellent hitter and he had a 143 wRC+ from 1998-2007 before falling off a bit. With Goldschmidt at 141, he is on track to at least keep up with Helton somewhat. The retired Rockie stands at 57.1 percent of the vote as of this writing according to bbhoftracker.com. Goldy has three more years on his contract with the Cardinals and is 34 years old. He should reach significant milestones this year like 300 HRs, 1,000 runs, and 1,000 RBIs. What he does in these next three years and possibly beyond will mean a lot to his Hall of Fame case. He is at 50.7 rWAR right now. If Goldschmidt can get to 65, Helton is at 61.8, he would solidify his shot at Cooperstown when he hangs them up.

Check us out on our socials:   
Twitter: @PTSTNews and @TalkPrimeTime
Facebook Page: Prime Time Sports Talk
Join our Facebook Group: Prime Time Sports Talk 
Instagram: @primetimesportstalk

Follow Johnnie Black on Twitter @jball0202

Main Image Credit: Embed from Getty Images

4 Comments so far

Jump into a conversation
  1. SocraticGadfly
    #1 SocraticGadfly 22 January, 2022, 23:45

    A half-fail on comparing Goldy to Tex, as Goldschmidt ALREADY has as many WAR as Tex did for his career, and over first 10 years, 141 RC is well ahead of 131. The only real hurdle Goldy will face is counting stats, as his WAR builds with more years. He’ll certainly play past the 3 years left on his current contract. He really needs to cross 2,500 hits, which realistically means 6 more years. 400 HRs will come quicker, and likely 450 with 6 seasons. That would also put him in the vicinity, at least, of 1,500 runs and RBIs. If he got 25 WAR over that time period, 75 WAR is a solid argument.

    Reply this comment
    • John Lepore
      John Lepore Author 23 January, 2022, 11:11

      You are assuming some serious success for Goldy over the next six years. While I don’t doubt it is possible he gets 450 HRs, 1,500 runs, 1,500 RBIs, and 2,500 hits, I think it is unlikely. His WAR will also likely take a slight hit even if he keeps hitting the way he does since defense and baserunning contribute to that somewhat. I’m thinking more like 350 HRs, 1,200 runs, 1,200 RBIs, and 2,000 hits by the time his contract is up. If he plays a couple more years he can reach even higher, especially the HRs. 75 WAR is going to be really tough.

      Reply this comment
  2. minoadoc
    #2 minoadoc 14 July, 2022, 08:31

    long way to go to get Fred McGriff numbers, who for some reason never got HOF traction

    Reply this comment

Leave a Reply